Book Review

‘Abdication’ by Juliet Nicolson

a jnSTORY: England, 1936.

The year began with the death of a beloved king and the ascension of a charismatic young monarch, sympathetic to the needs of the working class, glamorous and single. By year’s end, the world would be stunned as it witnessed that new leader give up his throne in the name of love, just as the unrest and violence that would result in a Second World War were becoming impossible to ignore.

During the tumultuous intervening months, amidst the whirl of social and political upheaval, wise-beyond-her-nineteen-years May Thomas will take the first, faltering steps toward creating a new life for herself. Just disembarked at Liverpool after a long journey from her home on a struggling sugar plantation in Barbados, she secures a position as secretary and driver to Sir Philip Blunt, a job that will open her eyes to the activities of the uppermost echelons of British society, and her heart to a man seemingly beyond her reach.

Outwardly affable spinster Evangeline Nettlefold is a girlhood friend to the American socialite Wallis Simpson, a goddaughter to Lady Joan Blunt and a new arrival to London from Baltimore. She will be generously welcomed into society’s most glittering circles, where one’s daily worth is determined by one’s proximity to a certain H.R.H. and his married mistress. But as the resentment she feels toward Wallis grows in magnitude, so too does the likelihood of disastrous consequences.

Young, idealistic Julian Richardson’s Oxford degree and his close friendship with Rupert Blunt have catapulted him from excruciating hours in his mother’s middle-class parlor to long holidays spent at stately homes and luxurious dinners in the company of a king. But even as he enjoys his time in this privileged world, his head cannot forget the struggles of those who live outside its gilded gates, and his uneasy heart cannot put aside his undeclared affection for May.

REVIEW: I was always intrigued by Wallis and Edward, and this novel sounded like it would be filled with interesting tidbits of their lives. I was wrong.

This had a potential of being a great story because of the three fictional protagonists who were “embroiled in the hidden truths, undeclared loves, unspoken sympathies and covert complicities that define the year chronicled”. Well, they were embroiled, but the telling of it felt flat because the characters were flat.

The “pitch-perfect prose” promised, was somewhat there, yet Ms. Juliet Nicolson has failed to capture my imagination of the era in “which duty and pleasure, tradition and novelty, and order and chaos all battled for supremacy in the hearts and minds of king and commoner alike”.

This story was not “as addictive as Downton Abbey”, or “as poignant as The Remains of the Day”. Far, far from it.

It is a fiction with disengaging and totally unbelievable characters set on a collision course in a predictable plot.

You’re better off re-watching Colin Firth in “The King’s Speech”.

Melanie for b2b

Complimentary copy provided by the publisher


1 thought on “‘Abdication’ by Juliet Nicolson”

  1. Hey, Mel! This is my kind of novel and I have also been interested in the Wallis Simpson “situation.” Sorry to hear that this story didn’t quite measure up.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s